Services Chevron Employees AT&T Employees Toyota Employees Client Login Schedule a Conversation
A wooden desk with a lamp, succulent, books, and a coffee mug overlooking a sunny vineyard

Evaluating advisors

Tax-aware portfolio management: how to choose

November 17, 2026
By Jamie Hargrave, Cadence Capital Investments
how to choose

On this page

Tax-aware portfolio management is the practice of running your investments to maximize what you keep after taxes, using tools such as tax-loss harvesting, direct indexing, and asset location. The right provider depends on your portfolio size, how complex your taxes are, and whether you want this bundled with a retirement plan.

Tax-aware portfolio management is the practice of running your investments to maximize what you keep after taxes, using tools such as tax-loss harvesting, direct indexing, and asset location. The right provider depends on your portfolio size, how complex your taxes are, and whether you want this bundled with a retirement plan. For the strategies themselves, see our companion guide, tax-aware portfolio management: which advisory firms use it.

The structure, stated plainly: investment advisory services at Cadence Capital Investments are offered through Prosperity Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor, which acts in a fiduciary capacity for those advisory services. Securities are offered through Fortune Financial Services, LLC, a Registered Broker/Dealer and member FINRA and SIPC. Insurance and annuity products are offered through licensed affiliates, so the firm is fee-based rather than fee-only: an affiliate may earn commissions on certain products, disclosed before any recommendation.

What are the options for tax-aware portfolio management?

Three kinds of firms offer it. The Tax Adviser, published by the AICPA, defines tax-aware investment management as actively maximizing the after-tax return an investor receives.

National wirehouses and large asset managers

These firms run proprietary direct indexing platforms. You own individual stocks in a separately managed account (SMA) instead of a fund, so losses can be harvested position by position. Expect higher minimums and dedicated tax-management teams. Choose this type if you hold a large taxable portfolio and want institutional-scale tools.

Digital platforms and robo-advisors

Digital platforms offer automated tax-loss harvesting at lower minimums. Choose this type if your finances are simple and you do not need an advisor relationship. Ask how the platform treats accounts you hold elsewhere, because it can only harvest what it can see.

Independent fiduciary advisors

Cadence Capital Investments is an independent fiduciary firm in San Ramon. Our investment management approach treats tax-aware management as one discipline inside a plan that also covers income and taxes. We have no proprietary products and no sales quotas to meet.

What should you compare when evaluating tax-aware management?

Four criteria separate a real tax-aware program from a label on a brochure. Use this list when you interview any advisor.

  • Tax management breadth: individual securities, harvesting through the year, asset location, and gain deferral, not only a year-end sweep.

  • Household coordination: losses in one account can offset gains in another across your whole household.

  • Fiduciary standard: the advisor must put your interests first, with no proprietary products to push and no sales quotas.

  • Fee transparency: any added cost for tax-aware strategies is disclosed and justified by the benefit you can expect.

Tax management breadth

The Tax Adviser notes that systematic year-round harvesting offers more opportunities than year-end harvesting, and that direct indexing in separately managed accounts typically provides the full security-level benefit. Asset location adds another layer: it places each investment in the account type where its taxes cost least.

Household coordination and fiduciary standard

A loss harvested in your joint brokerage account can offset a gain in a trust account only if one team sees both. Coordination also protects you, since IRS Publication 550 counts a spouse's purchase of an identical security as a wash sale. A fiduciary advisor is obligated to put your interests first, which matters most when two options pay the advisor differently.

Fee transparency

Tax-aware strategies often cost more than plain index funds, and that extra cost should earn its place. As one published benchmark, a large brokerage's direct indexing pricing listed a 0.40 percent annual fee and a $100,000 minimum as of 2025. Ask for the added fee in dollars and the tax savings expected from it, in writing, using your own most recent return as the example.

How do the options compare?

The three provider types differ most on coordination, fees, and whether tax-aware management sits inside a retirement plan. Scan the rows for the criterion that matters most to you.

CriterionLarge asset manager / wirehouseDigital platform / robo-advisorIndependent fiduciary advisor
Tax management methodDirect indexing in separately managed accounts, often with dedicated tax teamsAutomated, rules-based harvestingTax-lot management and harvesting chosen to fit your whole plan
Household coordinationConfirm whether losses offset across all household accountsConfirm how accounts held elsewhere are treatedCan be coordinated across household accounts; ask how
Fiduciary standardVaries by account type; ask in writingVaries by platform; ask in writingFiduciary duty on advisory accounts; confirm no sales quotas
FeesPercentage of assets; 0.40% at one large brokerage (2025)Percentage of assets; confirm the scheduleOften a wrap fee bundling management and planning
Minimum assets$100,000 at one large brokerage; $5,000 at another (2025)Lower minimumsSet by the firm; ask up front
Retirement planningOffered separately at many firmsTypically focused on investingOften included; confirm the scope in writing

Sources: published brokerage fee pages and Forbes, July 2025.

Tax management and household coordination

According to WealthManagement.com, a handful of large providers dominate direct indexing, so the differences you can act on are coordination and fees.

Fees, minimums, and fiduciary standard

One large brokerage's published pricing listed a 0.40% annual fee and a $100,000 minimum for US retail investors as of 2025. Digital platforms lead on low minimums. Large asset managers lead on institutional-scale direct indexing. On fiduciary status, none of the three types can be assumed, so ask for it in writing.

Integrated retirement planning

Independent advisors that offer planning often bundle it here. Retirement planning decides which accounts you draw from first, and that changes the taxes harvesting is meant to offset.

What should you ask before you choose a tax-aware advisor?

Seven questions cover method, coordination, fees, and fiduciary duty. Bring them to every conversation and compare the answers side by side.

Question to askAnswer to look forRed flag
Do you use individual securities or funds and ETFs?Individual securities in a separately managed account, with harvesting through the yearFunds and ETFs only, with a year-end review
How do you monitor wash sales?Every trade checked across all my accounts, including IRAs and my spouse'sOur software handles it, with no detail
How are losses coordinated across my household?Losses can offset gains across every account you manage for meEach account is managed on its own
What extra fee applies, and what benefit do you expect?A dollar fee and a dollar estimate of tax savedVague promises of tax savings with no numbers
Are you a fiduciary on all advisory accounts?Yes, stated in writingHedged answers or fiduciary status on only some accounts
Do you have proprietary products or sales quotas?NoPreferred in-house products
Do you report performance after taxes?After-tax returns shown next to before-tax returnsOnly before-tax returns

Questions about tax management method

The stakes are set by tax rates. Under current federal law, the top rates are 40.8% on short-term gains (the 37% bracket plus the 3.8% net investment income tax) and 23.8% on long-term gains (20% plus 3.8%). A harvested loss is worth the most when it offsets a gain taxed at those rates.

Questions about coordination and reporting

Ask to see performance after taxes. Since April 16, 2001, the SEC has required mutual funds to disclose after-tax returns in their prospectuses, so a tax-aware advisor can show the same measure for your portfolio.

Questions about fiduciary duty

Our guide to a fiduciary financial advisor in San Ramon covers what the standard means in practice. Whatever the answer, ask for it in writing and check whether it covers every account the advisor manages for you.

How much does tax-aware portfolio management cost?

The price varies by provider type, and it only makes sense next to the tax you expect to save.

Fee ranges by provider type

Large brokerages publish their prices. One lists a 0.40% annual fee with a $100,000 minimum on its direct indexing page (2025), and Forbes reported in July 2025 that another starts at a $5,000 minimum. On a $500,000 account, a 0.40% fee is $2,000 a year.

Digital platforms generally set lower minimums, so confirm the fee schedule. Independent advisors may charge a wrap fee that bundles tax-aware management with planning and retirement income strategy.

What shapes the fee structure

Four things move the price: portfolio size, how complex your taxes are, the number of accounts, and whether the service includes retirement planning beyond investing. Direct indexing fees also run above ordinary index fund expense ratios. Our guide to fee-based financial planning shows what a transparent fee structure looks like.

When the cost is worth it

Without gains to offset, harvested losses can reduce ordinary income by up to $3,000 per return, according to IRS Topic 409. A married couple filing jointly shares one $3,000 limit.

A $100,000 account that generates $3,000 of losses and has no gains can use all of it. A $1 million account that generates $30,000 of losses cannot, so most of that loss must wait for gains in later years.

Which approach should you choose?

Place yourself by portfolio size, tax complexity, and whether you want one coordinated plan.

  • Large asset manager or wirehouse: choose it if you hold a large taxable portfolio and want a dedicated tax-management team.

  • Digital platform or robo-advisor: choose it if your finances are simple and you want low minimums and automation without a dedicated advisor.

  • Independent fiduciary advisor: choose it if you want tax-aware management inside one retirement plan that also covers income, taxes, and protection.

Large asset manager or wirehouse

This fits when the portfolio is big enough that the fee is small next to the losses available to harvest. Confirm the team can see your 401(k) and IRA too, because a wash sale counts purchases made inside an IRA.

Digital platform or robo-advisor

A digital platform or robo-advisor works best when most of your taxable money sits in one account on the platform. If you hold other accounts elsewhere, you must avoid buying the same securities yourself within 30 days of a harvested loss.

Independent fiduciary advisor

Cadence Capital Investments works with East Bay households navigating Chevron and Lawrence Livermore retirement benefits and California's tax environment, and is not affiliated with either employer. If you hold Chevron stock, losses harvested elsewhere in your portfolio can offset gains when you sell vested shares, as our guide to managing Chevron RSUs for retirement explains.

What mistakes should you avoid with tax-aware investing?

Three mistakes cost investors the most. Check each one against your current setup.

  • Treating tax management as a standalone product: decide your income plan first, then choose the harvesting tool.

  • Wash sale rule violations: do not buy the same or a substantially identical security for 30 days before or after a loss sale.

  • Confusing deferral with elimination: estimate the later tax bill before you count the savings.

Treating tax management as a standalone product

A harvesting program cannot see your Social Security timing, pension income, or withdrawal order. Those decisions set your future tax bracket, and your bracket sets the value of every loss you harvest.

Wash sale rule violations

A wash sale happens when you sell at a loss and, within 30 days before or after, buy a substantially identical security, according to Investor.gov. That makes a 61-day window, and the IRS disallows the loss.

Automatic dividend reinvestments can trigger a wash sale too. If the repurchase happens inside an IRA, the loss is gone permanently.

Confusing deferral with elimination

Harvesting keeps money invested and compounding, which is a real benefit. A replacement bought at a lower price generally carries a lower cost basis, so the later sale may produce a larger gain.

All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Tax-aware strategies do not assure a profit or protect against loss, and this is general information, not tax advice; consult your CPA.

Serving Lafayette

Lafayette households often hold a mix of taxable brokerage accounts, IRAs, and employer plans, which is exactly where tax-aware coordination matters. Cadence Capital Investments works as a financial advisor for Lafayette and the Lamorinda area from its San Ramon office, with phone and video meetings available. Wealth management for Lafayette families starts with a list of every account, its tax treatment, and what each one is meant to fund. Schedule a complimentary conversation with Jamie Hargrave or call (925) 314-8513.

Ready to find your cadence?

Schedule a complimentary retirement review with Cadence Capital Investments and bring your latest brokerage statements. We will show you where tax-aware management fits in your plan and what it would cost, with no obligation. We are an independent firm in San Ramon, and we hold ourselves to a fiduciary standard on advisory accounts. Call (925) 314-8513 or use our contact page.

Jamie Hargrave, founder and financial advisor at Cadence Capital Investments

About the author

, Founder & Financial Advisor, Cadence Capital Investments

Jamie Hargrave has nearly 30 years of experience in financial services and founded Cadence Capital Investments in 2024, an independent, retirement-focused planning firm in San Ramon, California. The firm works with individuals and families across the East Bay, including Chevron, AT&T, and Toyota employees and retirees, on retirement income, investment management, and employer benefit decisions. Check his background on FINRA BrokerCheck.

Can tax-aware investing help if I don't have capital gains this year?

Yes. When losses exceed gains, the IRS lets you claim the lesser of $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately) or your net loss. Anything above that carries forward to later years, so a loss harvested now can offset a gain you realize when you sell a rental property or company stock.

Does tax-loss harvesting erase your tax bill?

No. Harvesting changes when you pay, and the benefit is keeping more money invested in the meantime. One exception to ask your CPA about: assets passed to heirs may receive a step-up in basis, which can change the eventual tax outcome, though the original gain is not erased.

What minimum assets do I need for tax-aware portfolio management?

Minimums depend on the provider type, and independent advisors set their own, so ask up front. What decides whether it pays off is your tax bracket and how much sits in taxable accounts. California taxes capital gains as ordinary income, with a top rate of 13.3%, which raises the value of each harvested loss.

What is the wash sale rule and how does it affect tax-loss harvesting?

When a loss is disallowed under the wash sale rule, it is not lost right away. IRS Publication 550 says to add the disallowed loss to the cost basis of the replacement shares, which postpones the deduction until you sell those shares. Tax-aware managers aim to check every trade so the loss you intended to harvest counts.

Can my portfolio go up in value while still generating tax losses?

Yes. A tax loss belongs to a single position, not to your whole portfolio. In an SMA, a stock sold below its cost basis can be replaced with a similar but not identical holding, so the portfolio keeps its market exposure while you record the loss.

Tax-aware portfolio management: which advisory firms use itHow to manage Chevron RSUs for retirementOur investment management approach

— Start the climb —

Ready to find your cadence?

Schedule a complimentary, no obligation conversation about your timeline, your income questions, and what a planning engagement would actually cover.

This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or insurance product, and does not account for your specific circumstances. Consult your CPA or attorney regarding your individual tax and legal situation. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Descriptions of employer benefit plans, compensation structures, professional designations, and regulatory standards are general, are drawn from publicly available information as of the publication date, and are subject to change. Confirm all plan provisions with your plan administrator and your summary plan description before making any election. Nothing here is a ranking, a recommendation, or an assessment of any other advisory firm.

Advisory services offered through Prosperity Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor. Securities offered through Fortune Financial Services, LLC, a Registered Broker/Dealer, member FINRA / SIPC. Insurance and annuity products are offered through licensed affiliates and agents; product guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing company. Because an affiliate may earn commissions on certain products, Cadence Capital Investments is fee-based rather than fee-only.

Cadence Capital Investments is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any employer, plan sponsor, plan administrator, or government agency named in this article. All company, plan, and product names are the property of their respective owners and are used for identification purposes only. Photographs are illustrative and do not depict actual clients.