Services Chevron Employees AT&T Employees Toyota Employees Client Login Schedule a Conversation
Two retirees reviewing documents with a financial advisor at a table with a scenic view

Retirement income

Goals-based financial planning: how to choose an advisor

November 17, 2026
By Jamie Hargrave, Cadence Capital Investments
how to choose an advisor

On this page

Goals-based financial planning builds your retirement plan around specific life goals, such as income, healthcare costs and legacy. The portfolio is the tool that pays for them.

Goals-based financial planning builds your retirement plan around specific life goals, such as income, healthcare costs and legacy. The portfolio is the tool that pays for them. Three firm types offer it to retirees: large brokerage-affiliated wealth managers, independent fiduciary planning firms and hybrid models. This guide covers how the process works, how it differs from returns-first planning, and how to choose an advisor in the East Bay. For a deeper look at funding each goal, see our companion guide to goals-based financial planning for retirees.

The structure, stated plainly: investment advisory services at Cadence Capital Investments are offered through Prosperity Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor, which acts in a fiduciary capacity for those advisory services. Securities are offered through Fortune Financial Services, LLC, a Registered Broker/Dealer and member FINRA and SIPC. Insurance and annuity products are offered through licensed affiliates, so the firm is fee-based rather than fee-only: an affiliate may earn commissions on certain products, disclosed before any recommendation.

What does goals-based financial planning actually mean?

Goals-based financial planning is a process in which your specific life goals, such as retirement income, travel, healthcare costs and legacy, drive every money decision. It works like planning a climb from the summit down: you choose the peak first, then the route.

A plan built around your life, not the market

The Financial Planning Association describes the sequence plainly: define your goals, identify the resources that can fund them, then choose the strategy. Its research says 'it's really the goals that will and should drive the financial plan.' Because every household's goals differ, no two plans should look alike.

Risk redefined: falling short of your goals

Traditional risk measures track how much a portfolio swings. Goals-based planning treats the main risk as falling short of your spending goals. Kiplinger notes that you may meet all your cash flow needs with a 5% return. Then there is little reason to take on more risk of loss chasing a higher one. Market losses are still real, because investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

The portfolio as an expression of the plan

Datos Insights says the portfolio is an expression of the financial plan. Assets are matched to the cash flows your goals require. The same report says five of the 10 largest wealth managers in the world treat goals-based investing as a core part of their value proposition.

Try a one-minute test. Write down your top three retirement goals, then read your latest statement and advisor emails for any mention of them. If none appears, your plan is likely returns-first, whatever label it carries.

How does a goals-based plan get built?

Planning is not strictly one-way, because what you learn at one step can send you back to an earlier one.

The five-step process

The Financial Planning Association's goals-based process has five steps. Your retirement goals belong in the first one.

  1. Define your goals.

  2. Identify the resources that can fund them.

  3. Determine the strategy.

  4. Implement the plan, which may mean opening new accounts or changing where savings go.

  5. Review it on a schedule and whenever life changes.

Goals before resources

When savings fall short, the strategy adjusts, and FPA notes that choosing a strategy may mean revisiting both goals and resources. CFP Board's practice standards ask planners to note how one goal affects others and to discuss goals that may not be realistic. A couple who wants winter months abroad and a grandchild's tuition may need to sequence them, and the plan shows that tradeoff years ahead.

What this looks like for retirees

For retirees, goals sort into fixed needs, discretionary wants and legacy wishes, and each gets its own investments and withdrawal approach. Kiplinger's coverage of retirement income points to Social Security, pensions, income annuities and bond ladders as sources for covering basic needs. Those bills stay covered even if stocks decline, while wants sit in a growth bucket that can ride out downturns.

How is goals-based planning different from traditional financial planning?

Traditional planning asks how your portfolio did against an index. Goals-based planning asks whether your money is on track to pay for the life you described.

Returns-first vs. goals-first

The two approaches differ on purpose, on how risk is defined and on how progress is judged. A few terms in the comparison are worth putting in plain language. Standard deviation measures how widely a portfolio's value swings up and down.

Risk capacity is how much risk your goals actually require you to take, while risk tolerance is how much of those swings you can stomach. Mean-variance optimization is a method that builds a portfolio to seek the highest expected return for a given level of those swings.

DimensionGoals-based planningTraditional planning
PurposeFunding your personal spending goalsMatching or beating a benchmark index
Progress checkProgress toward your goalsComparison to a benchmark
Definition of riskComing up short of a goalVolatility (standard deviation)
Portfolio stanceAs little risk as you need (risk capacity)As much risk as you can endure (risk tolerance)
Portfolio constructionAssets matched to the cash flows your goals requireMean-variance optimization based on tolerance for volatility

Source: Kiplinger (July 2024) and Datos Insights (May 2024).

The disconnection problem

Datos Insights found that most portfolios are disconnected from financial plans. Portfolio construction today is typically a mean-variance optimization process built on a client's tolerance for volatility, and such portfolios do not necessarily support long-term goals. If your statement shows a risk score but no goal, your portfolio may be one of them.

How many advisors actually deliver

InvestmentNews reports Cerulli Associates research from the second quarter of 2024. Only 25% of advisor practices meet the criteria for full-scope financial planning, well below the 60% who say they offer it. Ask any advisor who says 'planning' to show you a sample written plan before you hire them.

How do you check whether your plan is truly goals-based?

Run the checks below against your own documents, then decide which type of firm fits your situation.

The distribution-phase shift

Once you start drawing income, the question changes from how much your portfolio earned to how long your income will last. Kiplinger calls the five years before you retire plus the first five years of retirement the fragile decade. A prolonged downturn then can derail withdrawal plans. If you are 10 to 15 years out, your strategy should start shifting before your retirement date.

What a connected plan covers

A connected plan puts Social Security timing, tax-efficient withdrawals, healthcare costs and estate or legacy wishes in one picture. The retirement income planning work at Cadence Capital Investments, for example, decides which accounts to draw from and in what order, because Social Security claiming has no universally correct age. Households want this: per Cerulli research reported by InvestmentNews, 53% say they value a written financial plan, up from 38% in 2009.

Quick test: ask your advisor to show one page where your Social Security claiming age, withdrawal order and expected tax bracket appear together. Separate account reports mean no one is connecting them.

Which firm types use this approach

Three firm types offer goals-based planning to retirees:

  • Large brokerage-affiliated wealth managers, which bring broad institutional resources and platforms.

  • Independent fiduciary planning firms such as Cadence Capital Investments, which build custom plans around one household.

  • Hybrid models, which combine a brokerage platform with independent advisory services.

Does a pension or employer benefit decision sit within your next 10 years, as with Chevron or Lawrence Livermore retirement benefits? Favor a firm that can show you how it models those benefits. Cadence Capital Investments is not affiliated with either employer.

What do people get wrong about goals-based planning?

Most mistakes come from trusting a label, such as 'planning,' before checking the work behind it.

The label gap

The same Cerulli research found that about 57% of advisor practices lean toward case-based planning, meaning they focus on investment management. Many still describe their work as planning. Watch for these signs that the label is thin:

  • Reports compare you to an index and never mention progress toward your goals.

  • Risk is described only as a tolerance score or a volatility number.

  • Your goals were discussed once at sign-up and never again.

  • No one can say how the advisor is paid for planning.

Conflicts of interest

An advisor tied to proprietary products or sales quotas has a built-in reason to steer your goals toward something on the shelf. Investors notice: Cerulli reports that 55% weigh an advisor's understanding of their goals, needs and risk tolerance, compared with 46% who weigh performance relative to the market. The Cadence Capital Investments about page explains how the firm works: no proprietary products and no quotas.

Plans that drift

Goals change in retirement, and a plan built once will drift away from them. FPA research calls goals-based planning a dynamic process, because goals and resources change over time and the strategy has to follow. Ask for the date of your next review before you sign anything.

How do you choose a goals-based financial advisor for retirement?

Interview at least two advisors and ask each the same short list of questions.

Credentials and fee structure to verify

  • Which of your services are provided in a fiduciary capacity, and will you confirm that in writing?

  • Which certifications do you hold, such as CFP, and what planning work do they cover?

  • How do you charge, and what does the fee include? Convert any quote to a yearly dollar amount so you can compare fee structures.

  • How are you paid if I buy an insurance or annuity product?

Fee questions matter because, according to Cerulli Associates, only 21% of advisors charge for financial planning services separately.

What an integrated plan looks like

Ask to see a sample plan that shows income sources, withdrawal order, tax estimates, investment allocation and protection needs in one document. If the advisor hands you separate reports for each, you remain the one coordinating them. A Cerulli analyst told Morningstar that qualifying as full-scope planning includes tax and insurance.

Starting the conversation

Cadence Capital Investments is an independent, fiduciary financial planning firm in San Ramon. Advisory services are offered through Prosperity Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor that acts in a fiduciary capacity for advisory accounts, and advice is fee-based. Bring your latest statements and your list of top goals to the first meeting; an advisor who starts with the goals list is already practicing the approach.

Serving Danville

Danville households often reach retirement with several goals competing for the same dollars: staying in the family home, travel in the early years, and help for children or grandchildren. Cadence Capital Investments works as a financial advisor for Danville from its San Ramon office, a few minutes up San Ramon Valley Boulevard, with phone and video meetings available. Goals-based retirement planning for Danville families starts by ranking those goals and putting a dollar amount and a start date beside each one. Schedule a complimentary conversation with Jamie Hargrave or call (925) 314-8513.

Ready to find your cadence?

Retirement is a climb you only make once, and the plan should set a pace you can hold. Cadence Capital Investments works with East Bay families from its San Ramon office. Schedule a complimentary, no-obligation conversation or call (925) 314-8513, and Cadence Capital Investments will map where you stand and tell you plainly whether it is the right fit.

Jamie Hargrave, founder and financial advisor at Cadence Capital Investments

About the author

, Founder & Financial Advisor, Cadence Capital Investments

Jamie Hargrave has nearly 30 years of experience in financial services and founded Cadence Capital Investments in 2024, an independent, retirement-focused planning firm in San Ramon, California. The firm works with individuals and families across the East Bay, including Chevron, AT&T, and Toyota employees and retirees, on retirement income, investment management, and employer benefit decisions. Check his background on FINRA BrokerCheck.

What is goals-based financial planning?

It starts with what you want your money to do, then builds resources and strategy around it. CFP Board defines financial planning as a collaborative process that helps maximize a client's potential for meeting life goals, and says financial goals are 'one means to that end, not the end itself.'

What does a goals-based financial advisor do for retirees?

The advisor works through your goals with you and ranks them. CFP Board practice standards require planners to note how choosing one goal may affect others and to discuss any goal the planner believes is not realistic. For a retiree, that might mean weighing an early travel schedule against later healthcare costs before any money moves.

How often should a retirement plan be reviewed and updated?

FPA research says a goals-based plan should be reviewed annually and upon any major life changes. CFP Board standards add that planner and client should agree on how and when monitoring happens. The client must also report material changes, such as a health event. Put the annual meeting on your calendar.

Should I look for a fiduciary advisor for goals-based planning?

Many retirees look for one. A fiduciary is legally obligated to put your interests first for the services it provides in that capacity, but the duty may not cover every product a firm offers. Insurance and annuities, for example, are often offered through licensed agents, where commissions may apply. Ask which services the fiduciary duty covers and get the answer in writing.

Do advisors charge separately for goals-based financial planning?

Usually not as a separate line item. Since few advisors charge separately, most fold planning into an asset management fee. Ask whether pay comes through fees, commissions or both, and request the total annual cost in dollars based on your own account balance.

Goals-based financial planning for retireesHow to Compare Financial Planner Fee Structures in San RamonOur retirement income planning approach

— Start the climb —

Ready to find your cadence?

Schedule a complimentary, no obligation conversation about your timeline, your income questions, and what a planning engagement would actually cover.

This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or insurance product, and does not account for your specific circumstances. Consult your CPA or attorney regarding your individual tax and legal situation. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Descriptions of employer benefit plans, compensation structures, professional designations, and regulatory standards are general, are drawn from publicly available information as of the publication date, and are subject to change. Confirm all plan provisions with your plan administrator and your summary plan description before making any election. Nothing here is a ranking, a recommendation, or an assessment of any other advisory firm.

Advisory services offered through Prosperity Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor. Securities offered through Fortune Financial Services, LLC, a Registered Broker/Dealer, member FINRA / SIPC. Insurance and annuity products are offered through licensed affiliates and agents; product guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing company. Because an affiliate may earn commissions on certain products, Cadence Capital Investments is fee-based rather than fee-only.

Cadence Capital Investments is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any employer, plan sponsor, plan administrator, or government agency named in this article. All company, plan, and product names are the property of their respective owners and are used for identification purposes only. Photographs are illustrative and do not depict actual clients.